| The Daughter of
a "Shahid" Speaks out for Change |
I grew up on the other side of the border, in Gaza and Cairo. Born
and raised a Muslim at a time when President Nasser of Egypt was committed
to unify the Arab world and destroy Israel. Egypt mobilized the Arabs
in Gaza to start the 'Fedaeen' movement and make cross-border attacks
into Israel.
My father who was a high-ranking Egyptian officer was killed as a
result of these operations in Gaza. He was hailed as a national hero,
a 'Shahid.' Nasser vowed that all of Egypt would take revenge. He
made no mention of the heavy toll of death and destruction brought
upon Israel.
After my father's death, our family was lavished with attention for
a few weeks. However, widows of shahids, like my poor mother, were
left behind holding the bag alone after experiencing the devastating
blow to their families. Widows increased in numbers and had to deal
with facing life without a husband -- in a culture that respects only
families headed by men.
In Gaza elementary schools we learned the hatred of Jews, vengeance
and retaliation. Peace with Israel was never mentioned as an option.
Only the glory of battle was the ultimate honor. I was told not to
take any candy from strangers since it could be a Jew trying to poison
me. We learned fear of the word 'Jew', even though we never saw one.
We were told Jews were devils and evil. Young girls in school daily
recited Jihadist poetry while crying and pledging to give up their
lives as martyrs.
I heard Egyptians criticize Palestinians for not resisting Israel
enough and for going back to their work like nothing happened. Some
even accused Palestinians of collaborating with the Zionists and that
they were not trustworthy. In a culture based on pride and shame,
Palestinians were shamed, blamed, pampered and manipulated by the
rest of the Arab world. They were driven to get their honor back by
rejecting and terrorizing Israel. Living in peace with Israel was
only going to bring Palestinians more shame. . . . That is how many
feel even today.
The infrastructure and economy in both the West bank and Gaza were
neglected by Arabs. Palestinians were given weapons and rewarded for
jihad and terrorism. . . . While the children of the oil-rich Arabs
were living in luxury, Palestinian children were sacrificed as suicide
bombers.
I lived in the Arab world until age 30, witnessing three major
wars and the ever-growing influence of fundamentalist Islam. Freedom
of speech was suppressed. Citizens were basically indifferent to
the plight and oppression of other citizens. They developed a degree
of comfort in being ruled by dictators. Rulers were glorified and
treated as if they were Allah; even top generals kissed their hands
and the poor citizens stepped on each other to get favoritism. Statues
and pictures of dictators were everywhere---- songs praising them
on every radio station. I witnessed oppression of women, honor killings
of girls, female genital mutilation, and polygamy with its devastating
effects on family dynamics.
I was happy finally to leave all this behind and move to America
in 1978. Suddenly, I enjoyed freedom of religion and equality between
classes and races. My first job was given to me by a Jewish small
businessman whose parents were very kind and generous. I witnessed
Christians and Jews practicing their faith peacefully. I could not
help but contrast that with the hate, anti-Semitism and violence
my culture advocated. Among my Jewish and Christian friends, I heard
the words love, compassion, forgiveness and 'Shalom'. They eagerly
and sincerely asked: What can we do to have peace with Arabs? I
felt betrayed by my culture of origin for advocating violence and
talking about peace only in the presence of Westerners. I realized
that I had grown up behind a wall of fear, media lies, and deception
that separated us from the rest of humanity. These were thoughts
I did not yet dare to verbalize.
Nine years ago my bother's life was saved by Hadassah hospital
right here in Jerusalem. In time of crisis, Arabs trust Jewish expertise.
My whole family was grateful to the State of Israel and the doctors
and nurses of Hadassah for taking the higher moral ground and choosing
to do the right thing.
I visited the Middle East in the summer of 2001. I noticed a more
radical and angry population. Many didn't know of Suddam's atrocities
on his own citizens and fellow Muslims. They didn't know and maybe
did'nt care about the slaughter in Southern Sudan and Algeria. Arab
media managed to keep them misinformed about Muslim against Muslim
crimes.
Life in Egypt became even more difficult. I saw pollution, hazardous
materials and garbage along the banks of the Nile. I saw extreme
poverty, unemployment, high inflation, widespread corruption and
mismanagement. But none of this mattered to Arab media- - - all
they talked about was accusing Israel and America of causing all
problems.
We returned to the US on September 10, 2001. The next morning the
whole world changed. I knew, the very instant I saw the second plane
hit the twin towers that jihad had come to America. To my horror,
the country that had given me shelter, protection and hope was under
a monstrous attack from my own culture of origin. America is not
just a military Superpower, but also a moral power. Meanwhile, in
the Middle East, terrorists were called martyrs as Arabs celebrated
in the streets.
I immediately telephone to a number of Muslim friends. Without exception
they all made excuses for terrorism, denied the responsibility of
Muslim culture and concluded that 9/11 was an Israeli conspiracy.
These were not radical fundamentalists, but were moderate, educated
and well traveled Muslims.
I began to reflect upon the conditions of the society in which I
grew up, where generation after generation of Arabs were kept in
the dark about this great nation- - - Israel. I understood how a
psychological wall had been erected to keep Arabs blind as prisoners
of misinformation. The Arab population has become one of the most
indoctrinated in modern history. Arab propaganda machines consistently
deepen the fear and hate in the minds of Arabs with regard to Israel;
a tiny country of six million that is the object of a hateful obsession
by a 1.2 billion Muslims.
Jihad often starts within Muslim society rather than the outside
non-Muslim world. It often turns inwards against moderate Muslims
and governments. Those who do not practice Islam enough become a
target of Jihad by the radicals. The result is domestic turmoil,
political assassinations, fatwas and terror. Internal Jihad is thus
a constant danger from radicals within Muslim society, who terrorize
to enforce Islamic law.
Arab governments are constantly struggling to maintain internal
stability and unity- - - An external non-Muslim enemy is thus essential
to rescue Muslim governments. They would rather export popular and
well connected jihadists such as Osama Bin Laden and Ayman El Zawahri
rather than put them in jail. It is the convenient way to redirect
the violence to the outside world rather than have internal civil
war.
The infidels on the outside then become extremely useful. They say
infidels are out there, not in here; Israel, then became the most
useful enemy. And now, they are looking for an even larger enemy-
- America.
Moslem clergy have failed miserably in stabilizing their society.
Instead of being a source of comfort and wisdom, they have become
a source of hate, rage and subversion. They work the worshipers
into a frenzy of anger and paranoia against the West, the United
States and Israel.
I remember, as a young woman, visiting a Christian friend in Cairo
during the Friday prayers, and we both heard the verbal attacks
on Christians and Jews from the loudspeakers outside the mosque.
We heard "May God destroy the infidels and the Jews, the enemies
of God. We are not to befriend them or make treaties with them".
We also heard worshipers responding "Amen." My friend
looked scared, and I was ashamed. That was when I first realized
that something was very wrong in the way my religion was taught
and practiced.
These preachers are responsible for turning vulnerable young men
into terrorists. They have no respect for the legitimacy of any
government, and no government is 'Moslem enough' for them. Arab
governments are all struggling to stay in power. Always under the
threat of a coup d' ?tat. In this dynamic, only tyrannical governments
can survive.
Rather than take responsibility and reform, these preachers of hate
accuse Israel of wild conspiracies and for being behind Muslim terrorism.
They'd rather lie and accuse Israel of these evil deeds than take
responsibility. They call themselves men of Allah, but shamelessly
bear false witness against their neighbor Israel. In Islam this
is called "Fetnah". To accuse Israelis of conspiracy behind
9/11 is not merely an anti-Semitic discredited lie, but it is a
major sin committed by men of God. The way the Jews are being treated
in the Middle East is tragic and a disgrace! These lies must end
and reformation must begin.
However, reforming the way Islam is being taught for many generations
is not going to be easy since change must come from within. So far,
Muslims seem to be concerned with reformation only in the eyes of
the West. There is a huge well funded PR campaign by Muslims after
9/11. Their top concern is with the IMAGE, just the image, and reputation
of Islam rather than confronting their home-grown terrorists.
The same people who say Islam is a religion of peace are not offended
by the hate speech of preachers and terrorist defenders. Most Muslims
passively ignore the actions of terrorists. Rather than working
to rid Islam of those who give it a bad name, they continue blaming
the West and Israel. No demonstrations by any Muslim groups against
the barbaric beheading of Daniel Pearl, Paul Johnson, or lately
Margaret Hassan--- A British woman who dedicated 30 years of her
life helping Iraqis.
I had to break my silence After 9/11. I began writing and speaking.
A few other Arabs and Muslims also found the strength, commitment
and honesty in their hearts to speak out in support of the US and
Israel. I also salute the honorable kings of Jordan, the late President
Anwar El Sadat and other brave men who worked hard for peace. They
became an inspiration to all of us. It is not easy to speak out
in Arab culture.
I was privileged to meet with many people across America. I shared
tears and embraces with many women and young students. Americans
are simply puzzled by Muslim culture and often ask me: Why are Muslims
not outraged over 9/11? Why are "moderate" Muslims not
speaking out?
At one speaking event I met a woman about my age. We looked familiar
and slowly it dawned on us that we had both been students at the
American University in Cairo at the same time. At the time she dared
not admit to being Jewish. Shortly before graduating, she was forced
to leave Egypt along with her husband-who was tortured for 3 years
in Egyptian prisons after the1967 War for simply being a Jewish
man. I never knew there were Jews in Egypt at the time.
I began receiving many emails from Moslems who agreed with my opinions
and said they wanted to live in peace with Israel but too afraid
to speak out. I realized there was a need for a forum for them to
exchange ideas and speak freely, either anonymously or openly. And
so I founded the website Arabs for Israel. Just recently a Palestinian
woman now living in the US, who shares my views, sent an email which
I posted on the website. Out of habit I protected her by signing
it, "Anonymous." She wrote back: "No, put my name
on it," she said. "My full name."
The Muslim world is leaving the burden of eliminating terrorism
to the victims of terror, the US and Israel, instead of cleansing
the mess ourselves.
It is time for us Arabs to set ourselves free from the taboos against
self criticism. We need to clear our confusion between the idealism
of Islam and the reality of our actions and our teachings.
I am cautiously optimistic that the good side of human nature will
win. I see more and more journalists from Syria, Egypt and Saudi
Arabia speaking out. Supporting Israel does not take away from our
love of the Muslim and Arab culture. We need to change the paradigm
of how we view Israel. Many Arabs cannot understand how I can do
both, support Israel and still love my culture of origin. To them
I say YES, it can be done. It does not have to be black or white
or one at the expense of the other. If we just take the hate out
of the equation we are left with love 'or normal' for both cultures.
SIMPLE..
Radical Islam and hate speech are destroying the moral fabric of
Muslim society. . . No religion should end its services by the horrible
prayers to "Destroy the infidels" and no people should
be called "enemies of God".
Muslims around the world should be up in arms against the terrorists
who gave Islam a bad name. The culture of Jihad is in a head on
collision with the rest of the world and many believe we are already
in WWIII.
A Reformation movement from within the Muslim world is desperately
needed. There is plenty of virtue and goodness in Islam that should
be uplifted. It is the duty of good Muslims to bring out the compassion
and tolerance in Islam not only verbally but also through their
actions.
We need a Middle East culture that reflect the diversity of its
people and that has respect and equal rights for all --- Jews, Christians
and Muslims. The people of Israel contribute greatly to the richness
of Mideast culture and should be welcomed by its neighbors to flourish
and co-exist in peace.
Moslems could show the world that the Holy Land can be made truly
holy by giving the Jewish people the respect they deserve in their
homeland. Having seen Israel now for the first time, I am even more
committed to ArabsforIsrael. I am amazed and in awe of Israel's
resilience despite all the adversity. You are an inspiration to
the world.
I pray that the next Islamic conferences, instead of the usual bashing
of Israel, we hear prayers for peace with Israel. This will not
be a sign of weakness of Islam, but a sign of strength. What grace
and elevation to the stature and prestige of Islam that would be!
Prime Minister Golda Meier once said that the Middle East will see
peace when Arabs love their children more than they hate Israel.
I want to tell the former Prime Minister, God Bless her soul, there
is a considerable and growing number of Arab women and men, who
not only love their children, but also love Israel's children.
Thank you.
go back
|